www.drivebaby.com
Issue #21.32 :: 03/03/2010 - 03/09/2010
Would the real Jesus please stand up?

BY ANGEL CLEARY

AUGUSTA, GA – It’s tempting sometimes, when I get frustrated with dogmatic Christianity, to do what Thomas Jefferson did and chuck everything but the life of Jesus out the window.

After all, Jesus’ life is the paragon of behavior, right?

The truth is, for a figure whose life is supposed to be the blueprint for humankind, historians know very little about the details surrounding it.

What’s more, the Biblical books that give details about his life, according to Bart Ehrman, author of 2009 New York Times best-selling book “Jesus, Interrupted,” contain numerous inconsistencies.

He argues that, if read in the proper way, the story of Jesus’ life yields more questions than answers. To see these contradictions, and the bazillion others Erhman discusses, he says one has to read each story from the Gospels side by side, or horizontally.

One of the many contradictions is in the timeline of Jesus’ birth. In Matthew’s version, his family escapes to Egypt avoiding King Herod’s persecution. In Luke’s version, this fairly significant escape from death is missing, and instead Jesus’ family returns immediately to Nazareth after his birth.

 

 

He raises other issues as well, such as if Jesus was actually born in Bethlehem, or whether the authors wrote different stories trying to refer to ancient Hebrew prophesies about the Messiah coming from Bethlehem, the City of David.

Another glaring difference, he points out, is in the crucifixion story in Luke. In this story Jesus appears certain and in full knowledge of his coming suffering. Jesus makes multiple confident statements during his trial and leading up to his final death that indicate acceptance of his fate, even promising one of the criminals hanging with him eternity in paradise.

The moments in the Garden of Gethsemane, where Jesus sweats blood, he says were added in later manuscript copies, possibly copying other books. Yet in Mark, Jesus remains a suffering, silent martyr, uttering only these words of despair and uncertainty at the very end: “God, why have you forsaken me?”

In light of the discrepancies, Ehrman says, it is mistaken to believe that the Bible is the inerrant inspired word of God. Read side-by-side, the stories construct two very different Messiahs and, ultimately, lead to very different doctrinal conclusions, ultimately bringing into question everything from the virgin birth to atonement for sins, and just who the real authors of most of the New Testament were.

Before you dismiss this Erhman as another Dan Brown conspirator, consider this: In his own words, he grew up evangelical and graduated from Moody Bible Institute, a fundamentalist college. It was gradually, after a life of study, that he moved toward a more agnostic, historical-critical view of the Bible.

No critic of Jesus’ life as a paragon of human virtue will be without his detractors. Ehrman acknowledges and addresses his criticism head on. And he never takes a stab at conservatives who see the Bible as a literal path for perfection, even though it would be easy to do. In fact, one gets the sense he wishes he still believed it.

My own criticism is this: He uses hardly any citations when making generalizations about scholarship on historical Biblical facts. He says things like, “Almost all scholars agree on this point.”

I suppose we are supposed to believe him because of his prestigious position as a distinguished professor at UNC-Chapel Hill, but shouldn’t he of all people recognize the importance of including them in strengthening his position?

Even without citations, the literary argument alone is convincing. So, I say, read this book for yourself and consider the questions he asks. Make sure you have a Bible next to you, because reading the original Bible verses in their context are helpful to understanding his points.

To do this topic justice, though, you’d need at least three months of careful examination, cross-referencing his words with your copy of the Bible, an interlinear Bible with both the original Hebrew and Greek and their variations throughout history, Hebrew and Greek lexicons, copies of the complete writings of Josephus and Tacitus with indices, and a giant bottle of aspirin.

 
Comments
Well, you will never find the real Jesus by reading Mr. Ehrman. I've read Jesus Interrupted and was very disappointed with his treatment of the text. He speaks about textual criticism but in his works he doesn't even apply good logic when it comes to his conclusions about what is actually there. He definitely needs to stick with the Greek because he is absolutely horrible at interpreting Hebrew. If you want to see more about what I have to say about Mr. Ehrman you may visit here: http://goodnewsnow.wordpress.com/tag/bart-ehrman/ Other good treatment here: http://atheismisdead.blogspot.com/2010/03/bart-ehrmans-problem-part-1.html Have a great day all, and I mean that!
JohnMarch 3rd 06:40pm
I think to be fair, one must look at the other side of the coin and look at the highly qualified biblical scholars who are evangelicals. Rarely do we see authors such as Ben Witherington, NT Wright, FF Bruce, Gordon Fee, or Robert Stein quoted or interviewed on such issues. They are great scholars who are equal or higher on academic scale as Ehrman, but never get the air time as their counterparts such as Ehrman, Crossan, and Borg. It's definately more popular to promote the "shocking" revelations in the popular media.
ChrisMarch 3rd 07:58pm
I enjoyed Ehrman's other book, Misquoting Jesus and may give this one a try. Naturally anyone who holds the mainstream Christian version of Jesus as sacred and takes the bible as infallible is going to have problems with Ehrman's conclusions, but it doesn't take a bible scholar to see the obvious contradictions in the bible. It takes religious faith to not see them.
JoeMarch 6th 10:23pm
Professor Ehrman gives a facinating lecture at Stanford University several years ago that is a must see. Youtube it.
jonboyMarch 21st 12:23pm
Have your say
*
*
*
Your comment will be displayed after it has been reviewed by our editors. Please refer to our comments policy if you have any questions, or email editor@metrospirit.com.
Comments (4)

METRO SPIRIT site search by Metro Spirit, Augusta, Georgia
www.skatelandofaugusta.com/
www.coyotesaugusta.com
www.villaeuropa.com
www.augustacountry.com
www.theaugustamarket.com/
Circulation VerifiedCopyright © 2010, Portico Publications
Copyright | Portico Corporation
Powered by PLANet w3 CMS Content Management System
PLANet Systems Group 2010